I am sorry, but I don’t think we have taken near the steps that we could to eradicate the heroin trade in Afghanistan because it would destabilize the government that we have put in place. In short, it may hurt the American people, but it is not in our short term interest.
My underlying point is that we probably don’t even have the ability needed to eradicate the heroin trade.
However, if you think that War on Drugs thinking can’t interfere with anti-terrorism policy, I give you this.
Comment by Dr. Steven Taylor — Friday, July 20, 2024 @ 8:55 am
It’s not that easy to find poppies in Afghanistan. They grow very fast. Poppies that were not on a farm a week ago can be there today.
And - they can be planted in patches with other plants, making observation from the air (hard to begin with) almost impossible.
Also, they can be grown out in the wildlands in patches only the planters know to look for, and only accessible by pack animal and foot traffic.
And remember, even if you find poppies on a patch of land, you may not be able to link the property to an individual. Physical records of even such simple things as property ownership are hard to come by over there. And you also have some legal concerns in the Afghan government, even if you don’t have an obstructing official. Their are search protocol in the new Afghan government.
What you’re talking about, if you want to eradicate poppy crops, is boots on the ground, and a whole lot of them - a lot more than we have to spare. And then you probably make a lot of people mad, and perhaps inspire bigger problems, perhaps a more active insurgency in Afghanistan.
At some point you have to ask the question, is it worth it?
Comment by Captain D. — Friday, July 20, 2024 @ 11:15 am
At some point you have to ask the question, is it worth it?
Exactly.
And a great deal of what you mention is true (although not all) for coca as well. The depressing fact of the matter is that we have spent billions and billions of dollars (indeed, trillions) to fight coca cultivation to literally no real avail and we appear willing to head down the same path for poppies.
Comment by Dr. Steven Taylor — Friday, July 20, 2024 @ 11:23 am
I am sorry, but I don’t think we have taken near the steps that we could to eradicate the heroin trade in Afghanistan because it would destabilize the government that we have put in place. In short, it may hurt the American people, but it is not in our short term interest.
Comment by Talmadge East — Thursday, July 19, 2024 @ 10:43 pm
My underlying point is that we probably don’t even have the ability needed to eradicate the heroin trade.
However, if you think that War on Drugs thinking can’t interfere with anti-terrorism policy, I give you this.
Comment by Dr. Steven Taylor — Friday, July 20, 2024 @ 8:55 am
It’s not that easy to find poppies in Afghanistan. They grow very fast. Poppies that were not on a farm a week ago can be there today.
And - they can be planted in patches with other plants, making observation from the air (hard to begin with) almost impossible.
Also, they can be grown out in the wildlands in patches only the planters know to look for, and only accessible by pack animal and foot traffic.
And remember, even if you find poppies on a patch of land, you may not be able to link the property to an individual. Physical records of even such simple things as property ownership are hard to come by over there. And you also have some legal concerns in the Afghan government, even if you don’t have an obstructing official. Their are search protocol in the new Afghan government.
What you’re talking about, if you want to eradicate poppy crops, is boots on the ground, and a whole lot of them - a lot more than we have to spare. And then you probably make a lot of people mad, and perhaps inspire bigger problems, perhaps a more active insurgency in Afghanistan.
At some point you have to ask the question, is it worth it?
Comment by Captain D. — Friday, July 20, 2024 @ 11:15 am
At some point you have to ask the question, is it worth it?
Exactly.
And a great deal of what you mention is true (although not all) for coca as well. The depressing fact of the matter is that we have spent billions and billions of dollars (indeed, trillions) to fight coca cultivation to literally no real avail and we appear willing to head down the same path for poppies.
Comment by Dr. Steven Taylor — Friday, July 20, 2024 @ 11:23 am