Comments on: Adios Dollar Bill? http://poliblogger.com/?p=1067 A rough draft of my thoughts... Mon, 08 May 2024 17:37:17 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=1.5.1.2 by: Anonymous http://poliblogger.com/?p=1067#comment-3251 Wed, 31 Dec 1969 17:59:59 +0000 http://poliblogger.com/?p=1067#comment-3251 ]]> by: NANCY REYES http://poliblogger.com/?p=1067#comment-3248 Wed, 31 Dec 1969 17:59:59 +0000 http://poliblogger.com/?p=1067#comment-3248 You are behind the curve. First, they tried coins.: susan b anthony then the Sakajaweya. Both coins bombed. Dollar coins would be too heavy for the average pocket. Second, the way of the future is "smartcards". In Washington DC subway system, you put in a $10 and it zips thru when you get on and off, taking off the amount you spent. These cards are soft cardboard, but theoretically they could be cards, easily bought in stores like we buy long distance cards. You could also use a "smart chip" in a credit card, but this has a danger of losing your number and privacy issues. You are behind the curve.

First, they tried coins.: susan b anthony then the Sakajaweya. Both coins bombed. Dollar coins would be too heavy for the average pocket.

Second, the way of the future is “smartcards”.

In Washington DC subway system, you put in a $10 and it zips thru when you get on and off, taking off the amount you spent. These cards are soft cardboard, but theoretically they could be cards, easily bought in stores like we buy long distance cards.

You could also use a “smart chip” in a credit card, but this has a danger of losing your number and privacy issues.

]]> by: Daniel Morris http://poliblogger.com/?p=1067#comment-3247 Wed, 31 Dec 1969 17:59:59 +0000 http://poliblogger.com/?p=1067#comment-3247 If the cost of maintaining currency is so onerous, why don’t we reissue serious specie since it’s the more durable form. Try gold twenties and silver fives or tens in a limited issue and let consumers decide whether they like big denomination coins. Demand from banks and consumers would tell whether the impact justified a larger change. If the cost of maintaining currency is so onerous, why don’t we reissue serious specie since it’s the more durable form. Try gold twenties and silver fives or tens in a limited issue and let consumers decide whether they like big denomination coins. Demand from banks and consumers would tell whether the impact justified a larger change.

]]> by: Jeff Quinton http://poliblogger.com/?p=1067#comment-3246 Wed, 31 Dec 1969 17:59:59 +0000 http://poliblogger.com/?p=1067#comment-3246 I got into a similar conversation at Wrisley.com a few weeks ago that started out as a discussion of the decision to publish more $2 bills. I brought up European countries have coinages for smaller amounts and Canada having a $1 and $2 coin but as the site owner of Wrisley.com stated - dollar coins have never been that popular in the US. I got into a similar conversation at Wrisley.com a few weeks ago that started out as a discussion of the decision to publish more $2 bills. I brought up European countries have coinages for smaller amounts and Canada having a $1 and $2 coin but as the site owner of Wrisley.com stated - dollar coins have never been that popular in the US.

]]> by: Daniel Morris http://poliblogger.com/?p=1067#comment-3245 Wed, 31 Dec 1969 17:59:59 +0000 http://poliblogger.com/?p=1067#comment-3245 If the amount of money given in change has to increase (since people will be paying with larger bills), and there won&#8217;t be ones to give as change, won&#8217;t that multiply the amount of coin required? People tend not to carry as much coin, and are willing to forgo toting it around (since each one is not as valuable as a bill). Won&#8217;t that add to the number required? Also, the cash registers won&#8217;t have enough space; they&#8217;ll either be inefficient (adding costs), or will have to be replaced (adding costs). That could be a significant chunck of change. Finally, all the vending machines that take dollars will have to be retooled. My friend, Eric, <a href="http://www.megavending.com/">sells</a> vending machines; in the short term, at least, I think he would be severely damaged by the elination of one-dollar bills. Many others who use, stock, sell, or maintain vending machines would be hit as well. I don&#8217;t know what the trade studies looked like, but I doubt the $500 million savings would be passed on to the taxpayers in the first place. Having to bear the burden of all the associated costs could add up quickly. So I suspect it would do more harm than good. However, without having seen the trade studies, that&#8217;s just my opinion, and the usual disclaimers apply. Ciao If the amount of money given in change has to increase (since people will be paying with larger bills), and there won’t be ones to give as change, won’t that multiply the amount of coin required? People tend not to carry as much coin, and are willing to forgo toting it around (since each one is not as valuable as a bill). Won’t that add to the number required?

Also, the cash registers won’t have enough space; they’ll either be inefficient (adding costs), or will have to be replaced (adding costs). That could be a significant chunck of change. Finally, all the vending machines that take dollars will have to be retooled.

My friend, Eric, sells vending machines; in the short term, at least, I think he would be severely damaged by the elination of one-dollar bills. Many others who use, stock, sell, or maintain vending machines would be hit as well.

I don’t know what the trade studies looked like, but I doubt the $500 million savings would be passed on to the taxpayers in the first place. Having to bear the burden of all the associated costs could add up quickly. So I suspect it would do more harm than good. However, without having seen the trade studies, that’s just my opinion, and the usual disclaimers apply.

Ciao

]]>