Comments on: The Endless Lebanese Elections http://poliblogger.com/?p=7304 A rough draft of my thoughts... Thu, 08 Dec 2024 05:27:48 -0600 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.0 By: nice http://poliblogger.com/?p=7304&cpage=1#comment-193750 nice Fri, 02 Sep 2024 15:08:52 +0000 http://poliblogger.com/?p=7304#comment-193750 Veri nice site! Veri nice site!

]]>
By: Dr. Steven Taylor http://poliblogger.com/?p=7304&cpage=1#comment-72306 Dr. Steven Taylor Mon, 13 Jun 2024 23:57:12 +0000 http://poliblogger.com/?p=7304#comment-72306 I haven't gotten around to fixing that problem, but need to attend to it (the comment window). And good point about "rounds". I haven’t gotten around to fixing that problem, but need to attend to it (the comment window).

And good point about “rounds”.

]]>
By: Matthew Shugart http://poliblogger.com/?p=7304&cpage=1#comment-72141 Matthew Shugart Mon, 13 Jun 2024 18:59:05 +0000 http://poliblogger.com/?p=7304#comment-72141 First of all, I was wrong in an earlier comment. This window does not restrict to five lines. It is four. I regret the error. :-) Steven (or anyone else), can you point me to any really detailed description of how these elections work? I've been rather mystified by the partial descriptions I have seen. But the upshot seems to be that the outcome is largely fixed ahead of time--in two senses. One, there is a literally fixed share of seats for each of the recoognized "confessions." And second, the various parties strike pre-election deals that tend to leave very few seats really competitive on election day. Or rather election days. That last part is odd, too. This is a rolling process over several days and weeks. Small point. I wish reporting on the Lebanese elections would stop speaking of multiple "rounds" of voting. To me rounds means separate stages leading to the final outcome in a given seat or set of seats (i.e. French elections). That is not what is happening here. These are simply regions voting (once each) on seaprate dates. Maybe "phases" would be better? First of all, I was wrong in an earlier comment. This window does not restrict to five lines. It is four. I regret the error. :-)

Steven (or anyone else), can you point me to any really detailed description of how these elections work? I’ve been rather mystified by the partial descriptions I have seen. But the upshot seems to be that the outcome is largely fixed ahead of time–in two senses. One, there is a literally fixed share of seats for each of the recoognized “confessions.” And second, the various parties strike pre-election deals that tend to leave very few seats really competitive on election day. Or rather election days.

That last part is odd, too. This is a rolling process over several days and weeks.

Small point. I wish reporting on the Lebanese elections would stop speaking of multiple “rounds” of voting. To me rounds means separate stages leading to the final outcome in a given seat or set of seats (i.e. French elections). That is not what is happening here. These are simply regions voting (once each) on seaprate dates. Maybe “phases” would be better?

]]>
By: Dr. Steven Taylor http://poliblogger.com/?p=7304&cpage=1#comment-72103 Dr. Steven Taylor Mon, 13 Jun 2024 16:26:57 +0000 http://poliblogger.com/?p=7304#comment-72103 Saddly, it is fun that never stops, it would seem. Saddly, it is fun that never stops, it would seem.

]]>
By: Buckland http://poliblogger.com/?p=7304&cpage=1#comment-72101 Buckland Mon, 13 Jun 2024 16:19:16 +0000 http://poliblogger.com/?p=7304#comment-72101 Lebanon is a hard case. Those of us who push freedom and democracy for most every ill are left with egg on our face on a regular basis when discussing Lebanon. Aoun is one of the thugs (note: "one of the", not "the") that pushed Lebanon into the bloody civil war that precipitated a call from Arab states and acquiescence other players for Syrian invasion. His long time sparring partner, Walid Jumblatt was another. Now these bloody would-be dictators get another turn at building the country they tried so hard to destroy. So now the country is divided between Christians (the people with the money), Druze (the people with the best militias), and Hezbollah (the people with the most willing martyrs). Sounds like fun. Steven, a suggestion for this week's Friday Fun Meme -- Give your list of conditions to strangle democracy and return a people to civil war. My entry is now in. Lebanon is a hard case. Those of us who push freedom and democracy for most every ill are left with egg on our face on a regular basis when discussing Lebanon.

Aoun is one of the thugs (note: “one of the”, not “the”) that pushed Lebanon into the bloody civil war that precipitated a call from Arab states and acquiescence other players for Syrian invasion. His long time sparring partner, Walid Jumblatt was another. Now these bloody would-be dictators get another turn at building the country they tried so hard to destroy.

So now the country is divided between Christians (the people with the money), Druze (the people with the best militias), and Hezbollah (the people with the most willing martyrs). Sounds like fun.

Steven, a suggestion for this week’s Friday Fun Meme — Give your list of conditions to strangle democracy and return a people to civil war. My entry is now in.

]]>