January 15, 2024

  • el
  • pt
  • Gee Whiz, Guys: It's Just One Poll

    After watching some of the reaction to the Zogby poll which shows a three-way tie among Kerry, Dean and Gephardt in Iowa, I would like to say the following to the Chattering Class: take a deep breath guys, it's just one poll from a process that is notoriously difficult to poll.

    Posted by Steven Taylor at January 15, 2024 07:15 PM | TrackBack
    Comments

    Yep. Plus, as I noted this morning, this isn't a primary, it's a caucus. Two totally different things.

    Plus, no one seems to point out that it has a FOUR POINT statistical margin of error. That's not much of a sample.

    Posted by: James Joyner at January 15, 2024 07:28 PM

    Indeed, I think that it is 4.5

    Posted by: Steven at January 15, 2024 07:34 PM

    Then again, how accurate are the OTHER polls? Until we have some people really making irreversable decisions in voting booths, I wouldn't be too surprised to find any of the real candidates (i.e. not Kucinich or Sharpton) the actual preferred candidate.

    Posted by: Jackal at January 15, 2024 08:26 PM

    Of course, the poll corresponds to trends that have been making themselves clear over the past couple of weeks. Dean and Gepardt down, and Kerry and Edwards up.

    So it does say something different -- though it doesn't necessarily mean something different.

    Posted by: Mike at January 15, 2024 10:13 PM

    Sounds like we need to run those statistics again.

    Posted by: d-rod at January 15, 2024 10:49 PM

    When Dean was at 3%, Deaniacs didn't believe in polls. When he was up by double-digits, they figured the primaries were a formaility. Now that Dean is shrinking (rather than imploding) they are going crazy. Democrats are getting a real or second look at these guys and Dean is not doing well.

    Posted by: Anthony at January 16, 2024 09:40 AM

    First, a poll with 4.5% margin of error is still a poll (as compared to "not much of a poll"); it simply has about 550 respondents.

    The bigger problem as identified above is that it is a caucus, which means public debate and relatively public voting. This creates a huge tendency for "informational cascades" (a.k.a., the mob effect). Hence, the Iowa caucus is not a matter of preferences, but of institutional organization -- who can get the troops out en masse to influence other caucus participants.

    Posted by: John Lemon at January 16, 2024 04:50 PM
    Post a comment









    Remember personal info?