Comments on: Travels with Tom http://poliblogger.com/?p=6016 A rough draft of my thoughts... Wed, 24 Aug 2024 14:36:28 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=1.5.1.2 by: bryan http://poliblogger.com/?p=6016#comment-27911 Thu, 27 Jan 2024 18:31:46 +0000 http://poliblogger.com/?p=6016#comment-27911 Anecdotes aren't evidence, but for journalists, they are the meal ticket to a good lead. Look at almost any story about a major national issue. What's the first thing you see? An anecdote. The 80-year-old woman who has to decide between her medicine and her food. The "welfare cheat" who collects a check from the government while perfectly capable of working. The farmer who's having to sell his farm to a big co-op because of government policies. Etc, etc. To be honest, I think the deficiency is in the ability of journalists to really get the "bigger picture" behind the anecdotes. They (we) are frequently innumerate, and thus incapable of telling a compelling story with numbers, or even drawing proper inferences from the latest batch of spin statistics we get from the politicians. Or there are darker motives I don't want to consider. OTOH, politicians are famous for using the anecdote to no good end. Consider Reagan's famous welfare queen example, or the recent presidential campaign. Anecdotes aren’t evidence, but for journalists, they are the meal ticket to a good lead.

Look at almost any story about a major national issue. What’s the first thing you see? An anecdote. The 80-year-old woman who has to decide between her medicine and her food. The “welfare cheat” who collects a check from the government while perfectly capable of working. The farmer who’s having to sell his farm to a big co-op because of government policies. Etc, etc.

To be honest, I think the deficiency is in the ability of journalists to really get the “bigger picture” behind the anecdotes. They (we) are frequently innumerate, and thus incapable of telling a compelling story with numbers, or even drawing proper inferences from the latest batch of spin statistics we get from the politicians.

Or there are darker motives I don’t want to consider.

OTOH, politicians are famous for using the anecdote to no good end. Consider Reagan’s famous welfare queen example, or the recent presidential campaign.

]]>